Tuesday, August 23, 2022

Proposed Missouri Tax Cuts in Special Session: Pro and Con

Pro: Governor Mike Parson’s Office

On Monday, during a press conference at the State Capitol, Governor Mike Parson announced that he has issued the official call for a special session to make historic income tax cuts and extend key agriculture tax credit programs for a minimum of six years. The General Assembly will meet in Jefferson City on September 6, 2022, at 12 p.m. to begin consideration of Governor Parson's proposed legislation.

"My team and I have been working with our colleagues in the General Assembly and agriculture partners to formulate a plan to adequately extend our critical agriculture tax credit programs and pass the largest income tax cut in state history," Governor Parson said. "Today, we believe we have that plan and are ready to call legislators back to Jefferson City to get to work on behalf of our farmers, ranchers, and business owners and provide lasting tax relief to every taxpaying Missourian."

Tenets of Governor Parson's proposed tax plan include reducing the individual income tax rate, increasing the standard deduction, and further simplifying the tax code. Governor Parson's proposed plan includes:

–Reducing the top individual income tax rate from 5.3 to 4.8 percent, a nearly 10 percent cut;

–Increasing the standard deduction for individuals by $2,000 and by $4,000 for married joint filers; and

–Eliminating the bottom income tax bracket.

Governor Parson's tax relief plan means significant savings for Missourians each year. Below are a few scenarios that estimate state income tax savings for Missourians of different backgrounds, based on the State's tax structure:

–Senior making $20,000 per year - 100 percent decrease in tax liability;

–Single adult making $25,000 per year - 32 percent decrease in tax liability;

–Single mom with two kids making $35,000 per year - 21 percent decrease in tax liability; and

–Married couple making $125,000 per year - 11 percent decrease in tax liability. 

"Our tax cut proposal means that every taxpaying Missourian, no matter their background, income, or job description, will see a reduction in their tax liability," Governor Parson said. "Every Missourian will earn their first $16,000 tax free and married joint filers will earn their first $32,000 tax free, resulting in significant savings for millions of Missourians. Our plan puts more of Missourians' hard-earned dollars back in their pockets and aims to make it a little easier for families to put food on the table and gas in the car."

Governor Parson's special session call also includes the extension and creation of several agriculture tax credit programs intended to help develop key areas of Missouri's agricultural industry, the state's top economic driver. The sunset for each program will be for a minimum of six years. The call includes:

–Extending the expiration of the meat processing facility investment tax credit;

–Creating a tax credit program for retail dealers of higher ethanol blend fuels;

–Creating a tax credit program for retail dealers of biodiesel;

–Creating a tax credit program for Missouri biodiesel producers;

–Creating a tax credit program for establishing or improving urban farming operations;

–Extending the expiration of the Rolling Stock Tax Credit program;

–Extending the expiration of the Agricultural Product Utilization Contributor Tax Credit;

–Extending the expiration of the New Generation Cooperative Incentive Tax Credit;

–Exempting utility vehicles for agriculture use from state and local sales and use taxes;

–Creating the Specialty Agricultural Crops Act; and

–Amending the Family Farms Act to modify the definition of small farmer.

Con: Missouri Budget Project

Statement from Amy Blouin, President & CEO, Missouri Budget Project

While Missouri is fortunate to have the budget reserves it currently does, this situation is temporary, and is a result of short-term federal funds. Quite simply, relying on the current surplus to fund permanent tax changes isn’t fiscally sustainable, or responsible, and will ultimately require cuts to state services like we saw in Kansas a few years ago.

In response to COVID, the federal government provided billions of dollars to Missouri, which bolstered the state’s economy and state revenue. Those extraordinary federal funds also allowed the state to stockpile a large amount of general revenue. Governor Parson was reluctant to use short term federal funds for ongoing needs, and the same logic applies here.

Moreover, while Governor Parson focused on how certain struggling individuals might pay less in taxes, the proposals discussed today remain heavily weighted to benefit the wealthiest Missourians. What’s more, it would not benefit the thousands of Missourians who earn too little money to owe income taxes – even though they pay more in overall state and local taxes than their wealthy counterparts. In fact, in Missouri, the lower your earnings, the more you pay in state and local taxes as a share of what you make: according to the most recent analysis, Missouri families in the bottom quintile of income pay 9.9% of their income in state and local taxes, compared to just 6.2% for the wealthiest 1% of families.

Missouri can’t afford to enact the failed Brownback tax failure that devasted Kansas' budget. With Brownback’s policies, a budget surplus became a deficit, lawmakers had to make repeated and drastic cuts to state services, and the state’s economy suffered. After years of budget crises, that state’s Republican legislature reversed course and repealed most of the tax cuts. Because of the Hancock amendment, Missouri policymakers won’t have that option.

Missouri is the Show-Me State, and the Kansas failure showed us the devastating results of these kind of cuts to schools, public safety, healthcare, and the many other fundamental state services all of us rely on.


No comments: